Wednesday, 27 April 2022

Jim Kalbach on designing remote collaboration

Jim Kalbach, Chief Evangelist at mural

About Jim Kalbach

Jim Kalbach is a noted author, speaker, and instructor in user experience design, information architecture, and strategy. He is currently Head of Customer Experience at MURAL, the leading online whiteboard. Jim has worked with large companies, such as eBay, Audi, SONY, Elsevier Science, Lexis Nexis, and Citrix.

Jim is also the author of three books: Designing Web Navigation (O’Reilly, 2007), Mapping Experiences (O’Reilly, 2016), and most recently The Jobs To Be Done Playbook (Rosenfeld, 2020). He is also the Co-founder and Principal at the JTBD Toolkit, an online resource with learning, trainings, and content. Jim blogs at experiencinginformation.com and tweets under @jimkalbach.

Links

Transcript

[00:00:02] the combination of visualization and guided methods and structure to your meetings, it gets rid of zoom fatigue. When I first heard that term, I was like, what? What's that? Because I didn't experience it myself. And the other thing that I thought was what you need to be a little bit more intentional about how you're getting through your day of.

[00:00:20] Yeah. And so that's my biggest piece of advice is to structure and design. Essentially collaboration design, right? Design your collaborations.

[00:01:01] Welcome, welcome. Welcome to the managing road teams podcast. We are here with Jim Callbox today. Jim wrote two wonderful books, the jobs to be done playbook and experience mapping. Jim is also chief evangelists for mural. And Jim knows the in and out of whiteboards, which I think are an absolutely critical tool for. Remote work or possibly even hybrid work. But I guess we'll get into that in a bit.

[00:01:29] So Jim, could you say a few words about what it is that kind of got you. Into white boarding. And how you lend to at mural in the first place, your varied product background?

[00:01:43] Sure. So I spent a lot of my career in design and innovation teams, a couple of different companies, both internally in large organizations, but also externally as a consultant looking at things like human centered design and design thinking and innovation broad.

[00:02:03] And in 2015, I got contacted by Mariano's Suarez, Bhutan, the CEO of mural. They were very small company back then. And I joined the team because I had been steeped in design and design thinking, which is an important target for me. Very creative types and creative type of work, which I was very familiar with.

[00:02:26] But in my previous role, I worked for Citrix, the makers of go to meeting and go to webinars. So I was in the remote collaboration space as well too. And I always felt that one of the biggest challenges of remote collaboration was creative work. How do you get a team of designers or, an innovation brainstorming session?

[00:02:47] How do you do that with. Folks. So when I came to mural, it was really a combination of those two interests, my interest in remote collaboration in general, but also in creative work and design thinking type work.

[00:03:02] So why are whiteboards so helpful in. And remote collaboration and remote work.

[00:03:08] Yeah. I have this concept of what I call the digitally defined workplace. Which if you think about it in terms of jobs to be done that a team collaborating. Four or five core jobs that they need to get done. They need to communicate in real time. They need to communicate asynchronously.

[00:03:28] They need to have a shared space where they gather documents and things like that. And if you walk around any office building, you'll also see evidence of a need for the job of collaborating. And a lot of people say I'm not a creative or I'm not a designer. I don't collaborate visually. And I've had people tell me that.

[00:03:48] And then I will go over to their workplace and it's full of sticky notes and there's a whiteboard behind them. And there's flip charts all over the place. All of that type of work is visual work, it's not happening in an Excel sheet. And what happens is that tends to happen outside of the computer actually.

[00:04:04] Particularly before the pandemic and when we took the office away from folks during the pandemic, for instance, there was this need, right? So I think from when I think about white boarding it's actually a need that you have when you collaborate to express yourself in a visual way to draw a square and a circle and connect them with a line and say, we need to get from point a to point B as a team.

[00:04:27] There's an aligning effect that, that has right by expressing yourself visually you're able to elevate the conversation and express yourself in a different way. Then you can, if you're just talking or if you're just typing.

[00:04:39] Visual collaboration is complimentary to other modes of collaboration that we had that we already had, whether we knew it or not. We already had it with sticky notes and flip charts and whiteboards in our office. And the digital version of that gets that job done for us.

[00:04:53] When we're collaborating in a team, we need a way to express ourselves visually, even if you're in finance or HR. Again, this isn't just for creatives. This is work in general. Has this need to to be expressed and represented visually.

[00:05:06] How are you defining collaboration here? Exactly.

[00:05:09] Yeah, that that's a great question. And we're working on a more precise definition, but it's when two or more people come together and they have a specific challenge or problem that they're trying to solve with a common mission, that there's a common purpose for this group of people to collaborate.

[00:05:27] Typically, when we talk about collaboration here at mural, we're thinking about workplace collaboration. But we also serve educational institutions. So there might be a student project team, government organizations. And I think that definition still holds true group of people coming together, bending for a common cause.

[00:05:45] And trying to problem solve for a common cause that could be very temporary. It could be a single session and a group of people come together dynamically. It could be a permanent team of people that come together. it can be ongoing collaboration, between people and teams as well, too.

[00:06:01] So I think about all of that as collaboration, essentially individuals, human being. People coming together and trying to solve a problem together. And they do that through interactions. There are certain interactions that that they have. And again, just going back to my previous response, there's a certain type of visual interaction that collaborating teams have always needed.

[00:06:23] That the idea of a virtual whiteboard, isn't just, oh, it's another tool that does the same thing as my other tools. It actually does something fundamentally different for that collaborative.

[00:06:33] So fundamentally different because it's digital or

[00:06:37] because there's visual because it's visual that I can, right now we have audio and video here, you and I can also type in the chat if we were also expressing parts of our conversation, visual.

[00:06:49] It will take the conversation to a different place and to a different level in terms of understanding, we can actually model what we're talking about and we can see it. I can see what you're thinking and you can see what I'm thinking in terms of shapes and sticky notes and arrows and all kinds of things.

[00:07:04] But it also allows for a different level of participation as well, too, because when you're talking or typing, it tends to be the tr the traffic is regulated one by one only one person can talk at a time when you're thinking visually, actually multiple people can be expressing themselves at the same time.

[00:07:21] So it actually gets it gets more inclusion and you potentially get a more diverse type of perspective that can be represented as well, too. So it's all of that. When I talk about visual collaboration, it's all of that.

[00:07:33] In the post pandemic, modern world, if we're not talking about doing that digitally, and if we're not talking about doing that in the cloud, where it's we can't go back to is taking pictures of whiteboards and transcribing and sticky notes. We're going back to the office, but we can't go back to that. We have to pretend like we're in the 21st century work is now digital, including the visual. It would be, imagine a memo coming around your office.

[00:07:57] Remember we used to do memos and used to have a name and you check it off. Like I saw this memo. And then the memo to imagine. Yeah, it sounds funny now, but that's essentially what did very visual collaboration was before the pandemic was essentially like communicating like a memo. We send an email, we send a slack.

[00:08:14] Why isn't our visual collaboration, digital, Nan. I think that's the wake-up call that people got during the pandemic. And this category of whiteboard is now more and more commonplace. I can't tell you how many times Luke I'll pull up mural and people will be like, oh yeah, we've used this before.

[00:08:29] I didn't get that before the pandemic before, what is this thing? So I think we've gotten sensitized to this metaphor of a virtual digital. But for me it still goes back to that fundamental job that it gets done when we're talking and having a conversation, particularly if it's a complex problem solving that problem visually.

[00:08:48] It literally offloads cognitive space. So we can think better together. We literally think better together when we're collaborating visually. And it's really that that I'm most interested in the technology. Yeah. Technology is important, but it's really the effect and the impact that visual collaboration can have on a team.

[00:09:07] Yeah. Yeah. I think in my experience, it's. Everything that you mentioned, but it's also visual interplaying with the conversation and back. So it's, it feeds on each other. Yeah, exactly. You build meaning in a different way. Like you can have a really interesting conversation with somebody and get to a new point.

[00:09:24] I'm not saying that's not that I can even have really meaningful slack conversations. But very often there's a type of conversation and problem solving when you really have to get together and get along. And you have to be able to include a lot of voices. So diversity of perspective, and the problem is complex, right?

[00:09:43] It's those types of conversations and interactions that, that, where visual collaboration. It's not just, it's not just another way to think. It's a different way to think as a group of people, it actually elevates your collaboration in a new.

[00:09:59] It's interesting. You also mentioned schools and education working in a software context that quite often the problem with software team faces is that they have a complex problem. And if they're all remote, then a whiteboard is actually a great way to do that because it's it's like learning is the biggest bottleneck in this type of work.

[00:10:19] Yeah. What are your thoughts on the application of in the context of problem solving specifically Mike and whiteboards. What are things that, that you've seen people do that, that work well with with whiteboards?

[00:10:32] One of the, one of the effects, one of the phenomena that we see, we call it a blank canvas paralysis.

[00:10:40] That if you just pull up a blank canvas and you have a group of people with a complex problem that they're trying to solve and say, okay, go there's this lack of knowing where to start, particularly if there's a group of people who's going to go first, what are we doing? But I think there's a fairly simple and prevalent solution to that, which is to use what we call guided math.

[00:11:03] So from design thinking, for instance, there's a whole class of methods out there where you can actually break down the challenge that you have into smaller chunks. And instead of just improvising the collaboration. So a lot of people think about whiteboard as being white blank. That is, and then you fill it in with scribbles, but you can actually pre structure the conversation.

[00:11:26] Using the tool like mural with guided methods so that I can get a group of people and have the playbook, so to speak the rules of engagement. We're not just improvising the conversation on a blank whiteboard, and then it's it just grows organically or not. You can actually say, let's do an exercise like rose gardens.

[00:11:43] Rose thorn. Bud is a great exercise to analyze a problem from different angles. The roses are the positive things that Thrones that a negative things in the buds are there potential things. If everybody just takes two minutes and puts rose storm buds, and then you cluster. So it's okay. Heads down for two minutes then cluster.

[00:12:00] Okay. Now let's prioritize the clusters and you can vote on those. Okay. Now let's put those on a two by two matrix to see what we're going to do next quarter. You can actually get from point a to point B. Let's say you're planning a sprint or you're planning the roadmap for next quarter. You can get from point a to point B, not by staring at a blank canvas together and scratching your head, but actually structuring the conversation and structuring it.

[00:12:25] So I can give you the instructions and you can print them out on a PDF, but I can also just show you, Hey, we're going to do rose thorn, bud clustering, prioritization matrix, and then go into the roadmapping so that your collaboration is not improvised. You actually have a score.

[00:12:39] I'm a musician, right? So I think. Sheet music, I can have the sheet music, so we're all reading from the same score, that's something that, that we think is funding will fundamentally change collaboration is if it's a lot more deliberate and a lot more.

[00:12:56] Yeah, I can definitely see how for somebody new to it, that would make it a lot easier. It's an interesting interesting problem. Similar to when you're writing and you have a blank page.

[00:13:06] Yes, exactly. And I like to think when I structure a meeting or workshop, I do it spatially. So I started in the upper left of a canvas.

[00:13:14] I like to go right and left. Some people like to go top and bottom, but I'll put a big number one. We're going to do this together right now. I have instructions there and then I put a line and then you move over and then I do number two. So my, my meeting agenda is represented visually. We're going to go from left to, it also lets everybody know that I'm working with what we're going to do. They can see the beginning and the end before we even get started and I just moved the team across. So it's almost as if the visualization and the canvas is facili facilitating my meeting for me, I'll even put breaks in there oh, we're going to take a break at this point.

[00:13:47] We're going to do this for an hour. Take a break, come back through this. So the meeting agenda is spatially represented on the canvas as well too. And then we fill that. Through the guided methods, we fill that in with stuffs that, and that gets us to, to our answer at the end. Again, it's being about being deliberate about collaboration and about designing that collaboration experience.

[00:14:07] And I think the canvas adds a whole new dimension for that.

[00:14:10] You briefly mentioned in passing the effect on alignment that working this way has, why do you think that is?

[00:14:18] I think because there is a when you're thinking about, let's just say a digital whiteboard, it allows people to express what they're thinking in a different way or even.

[00:14:29] Cause sometimes, you might go into, let's just say a sprint planning meeting and there's a set of requirements and somebody will read them off or discuss them. And then there's a group of people sitting around, what's in their mind, what are they thinking? Do they understand those in exactly the same way?

[00:14:44] If we could get them to express what they're thinking as well too. So this idea of participation is really important. You can then see if you're all aligned or not. Literally see it. Do we all have the same. Of what we're headed towards.

[00:14:58] Jeff Patton, he wrote a book called user story mapping. He has a great great little cartoon in. Where there's three people. And at the beginning they have like thought bubbles and one has an orange, a triangle, and the other's thinking of a square and the other thinking of a circle. And I've been on a lot of projects where everybody nods and says, yeah, we're all together. But then if you looked in their minds, they actually have three different opinions or mental models of the thing that they're trying to solve for. And then the next frame of his cartoon is they put it out on a black. They actually put their circle and they said, oh, we're not aligned.

[00:15:31] So this idea of expressing yourself visually helps you then negotiate your different mental models so that you can get closer to a harmonized view of the world.

[00:15:43] One of the things that are really Useful in terms of alignment across departments, is this whole idea of customer experience mapping? You've written about it., quite a lot of depth and nuance if somebody was thinking about doing kind of a customer experience map for the first time, how would you suggest doing that kind of thing to help align with.

[00:16:04] Sure. And I think, for me, just get, just to relate that back to your previous question to a customer journey map for me is essentially a collaboration tool. It's a way for some people to go out and observe the customer experience, right? Cause not everybody in an organization has contact with customers.

[00:16:22] But the people creating the map maker would have the luxury of being able to. Talk to people and investigate data around the customer experience. And they could take that data and write a 50 page report on it and say, here's all the things that we found and send around a 50 page report.

[00:16:39] But we know what happens with 50 page reports when they get sent around, people don't read them or they don't connect. What's on page three with what's on page 17.

[00:16:48] Alternatively I could take that information, that insight that I gathered and represented visually in a single.

[00:16:54] And that's what a customer journey map is. It's a compression of observations that you've made about the outside world human experiences in some way. And I compress it into something that gives an overview. And by visualizing that overview, I get this massive compression of information. 50 pages of, written texts would be a single overview where I can actually see cause and effect in the same overview.

[00:17:19] So I can say, oh here at this step, if we mess this up, that's going to cause this effect downstream. And it's also something that's compelling and engaging. So the idea of creating a journey map is creating these compelling, engaging artifacts that represent a lot of information.

[00:17:36] And the key point there is an alignment from the inside to the outside. We want our perspective as an organization to align to the. Perspective. That's essentially what being customer centric is. But then that diagram, that artifact becomes a collaboration tool inside and I call that insight.

[00:17:54] Alignment. So there's two types of alignment you're looking for. I want to get the outside in perspective, but then I got to get the teams that are trying to deliver that experience that you want aligned as well too. And the visualization helps with that as well too, because the marketing team can see itself in a journey map.

[00:18:11] The product team can see itself in the journey map. Everybody in the organization can see how they fit into the bigger picture in a single overview. And it becomes a collaboration tool at that point. Let's discuss, what are we going to prioritize next quarter? I'm just using that as an example, and you can have a conversation.

[00:18:28] So for me, the visualization of a map, a journey map is really it's to create an artifact that you can have a conversation around and you can use it as a diagnostic tool with a team to collaborate and come up with the solutions and the answers to the problems that you find together. So knowing that I think has impacted.

[00:18:46] You're trying to do two things, align the outside world to the inside. And you're also trying to foster a conversation as well, too. So the map maker, before you get started, you have to keep that in mind. And there's lots of different techniques that you can use. And methods out there.

[00:19:00] There's customer journey maps and service blueprints and mental model diagrams. And that's what I talk about in my book that you mentioned all these different types of maps, but they're essentially trying to do the same thing, which is trying to do these two different types of alignment.

[00:19:12] And the simplest place to start is with the chronology. Typically we think of an experiences things that happen to individuals over time. So it's a chronology and then there are different layers of information and the chronology is usually represented as columns and the layers of information are usually represented as rows.

[00:19:32] And I start journey mapping with actions, thoughts. And what are the actions, thoughts, and feelings of the people that I'm studying over time. So if you have a timeline and then put actions, thoughts, and feelings, that's a great place to get started, I think.

[00:19:45] Just to make it a little more concrete? Yeah. How would you describe a company that's aligned with the customer, but not aligned horizontally as you were saying? What does it, what does that look like? Yeah that's actually common. I think, cause particularly in the past five and 10 years, I think.

[00:20:00] Data about the customer experience is not lacking in organizations. We have everything from surveys and NPS and live usage, data of digital products research teams that go out and do qualitative research. Usability testing is common. We don't necessarily lack information about our customers and what they're experiencing, but is it actionable?

[00:20:23] And I think that's really the purpose of journey mapping as a verb. It's not about the map, but it's not about the now. And it's about the mapping. There's a process of creating the map and there's a process of having a conversation around the map. It's really trying to make sense of the data that you're getting about the experiences that you create, right? So they does not add, we're not lacking data. What we're lacking is a way to actually interpret that data and to make sense of it. And again, that's a collaborative exercise. So a journey map helps you do both of those things make sense of it because what you can do is overlay activities.

[00:20:57] I was talking about guided methods, right? I think my next book on journey mapping is going to be a series. Guided methods. Once you create the map what are you going to do with it? There's all kinds of prioritization techniques. What's the most important point for us. What's the most important point for the customer?

[00:21:13] Do those align? Where's the biggest pain point where you, our competitors Excel and we don't, and you can use that model of the world, the map itself as a springboard into analysis, and conversation. On top.

[00:21:26] You mentioned the outside in view and I guess you're referring to the jobs to be done angle. Mental models and job maps, I think we're closest to the customer. How are these tools and approaches useful for let's say strategy for.

[00:21:43] From a jobs to be done perspective, there's an artifact called. Which is really not looking at it. Doesn't look at your relationship with a customer as a paying customer. It's looking at what they're trying to get done independent of your solution. So it's similar to a customer journey map. A job map is similar to a customer journey map, but it has a different perspective because it's not about your solution.

[00:22:07] In fact, in jobs to be done, we go a great line. To expunge, any reference to technology solutions or methods in the language, and we're not looking at how do people become aware of my solution? How do people decide to buy my solution? Why do they stay loyal to. Those are the three points of a customer journey map, by the way.

[00:22:26] We're really looking at what are they trying to get done independent of my product or my solution. And that gives you an independent view of the job to be done. When you're talking about jobs to be done, you your unit of analysis is the job.

[00:22:39] And a job map represents that individual. So you can actually then say, okay, where is the biggest point of intervention? If I understand what the individual, the people that we're trying to solve, if I'm understanding what they're trying to get done independent of my solution, just what their objective is.

[00:22:56] What we can then do is say, where are the biggest levers? Are there points of intervention where strategically we would make the most difference or strategically where the market and competitors haven't So you can actually find new playing ground at a strategic level from something like a job map.

[00:23:13] And guess what a job map is also visual, and it has that same effect. It's something you can put up and use as a conversation piece and do another layer of conversation and analysis through guided methods and visualization to come to, an agreement within your team.

[00:23:30] Just to , jump topics again, digging further into the question around collaboration what are the most. Common are the most important jobs around working together remotely in general? How do you think about that?

[00:23:45] I think about it in, in two layers actually. And this is a model that I'm hopefully going to be writing about a little bit more in the near future.

[00:23:55] when a group of people come together, I think there are two fundamental jobs. That they have in front of them at the highest level is they come together and this is why they come together is to solve a problem or a challenge. There are methods and then there's a workflow to get that done. And we can look at models of innovation or design thinking process. Agile has its process to help teams solve problems.

[00:24:18] I think there's another layer though, that became very evident during the pandemic, which is teams have to connect. At an interpersonal level. W one thing that we learned during the pandemic is work is social.

[00:24:31] And I don't mean you have to like your colleagues and things like that, but there are two or more human beings coming together, collaborate. Guess what? They bring their human beingness, their human humanity with them. And there's this very social component to work as well, too.

[00:24:45] And what we've found is one of the big challenges coming out of the pandemic is discussing. Now that people are, did feel disconnected. And there's studies that show this as well, too, that okay. I'm working at home now, during the pandemic and I can be productive personally, but team productivity and team connectedness is suffered. So that what we're seeing is projects get going. And again, even everybody might be individually productive, but the project has to start over. Because the teams weren't aligned because they're not connected, or people are very dissatisfied with their work condition because they're not connected to their colleagues anymore at a human level.

[00:25:24] When we're thinking about designing a collaboration experience, I think you need to think about how are the teams going to solve their problems together? How are they going to get from point a to point B, but how are they also going to connect. And we have to make that deliberate in the past, it was basically well went to the office together and that the connection magically happened, the water cooler moments, the happy hours, the cat, the Cantina, meeting our colleagues, the coffee breaks and things like that. Without those things. Or you can, those things still exist, right? Because you still go to the offices and meet in person, but we can't assume that's always going to happen with that within every team that I think we also have to make that other layer, we have to make both problem solving and connecting as human beings, we have to make that.

[00:26:07] And there are ways to do that, that if we're collaborating remotely, there are exercises and activities that we can do to help get to know each other a little bit better. And I'm not talking about, team building activities. Those are good. But those happen, like what, like once a year, once a quarter or something like that, I'm talking about every time you connect, what, where are those little moments where you're connecting and reflecting?

[00:26:29] As a team about yourself and about the group of people. it's not about making friends, I'm not talking about, Hey, you have to be, you gotta be, you gotta be a social person. Now it's just about connecting, as a team, there has to be a cohesiveness there at a human level as well, too.

[00:26:45] So solving problems and connecting, I think are the two big jobs that a team has to do to collaborate.

[00:26:50] As you were mentioning that, I think a really. Difficult point, is the first moment a team comes together? What are your thoughts on that? About how to structure that possibly with the use of some somehow, using a whiteboard

[00:27:05] that's that's what we do at mural.

[00:27:07] We even have templates and things for like team kickoff, and Again, just thinking about those two facets are those two jobs to be done. We need to solve a problem together, but we need to connect. So if I were structuring a team kickoff, I would want to have everybody introduce themselves and disclose something that they're comfortable disclosing.

[00:27:25] I'm not saying again, it's not about making friends, but there is a relationship. There's a work relationship that you have to build with your colleagues. And I would also want to get aligned on what's the problem we're trying to solve. And I would have activities that would be interleaved. Right again, it's not about saying, oh, we're going to take a day off and do team building.

[00:27:43] It's about every time you interact, even at the beginning of a project, how are you going to get to know each other as people? What's the modus operandi of each of these people? What are their perspectives that they're bringing to the table from their jobs and their role? What are their motivations, right?

[00:27:56] How are these people as individuals? What type of person are they? Those types of activities and conversations. As well as what's the problem we're trying to solve right together. Google ventures did this study on high performing teams. And one of the most important factors that is a leading indicator of a high-performing team are things like psychological safety.

[00:28:17] Do you feel safe speaking up in front of that group of individuals that you're collaborating with? Dependability. Can you rely on them to get done with they're done, right? You don't build psychological safety and dependability. If you're only focused on the problem solving side of things, you also have to be deliberate about building up those relationships in those ties.

[00:28:37] So I do feel psychologically safe and I do feel like I can depend on my colleagues. So it's again, it's at the beginning and it's to your question. It's really important to establish, that playing field that we're going to talk about psychological safety and dependency, maybe not directly, but it's going to be something that we're going to be actively and deliberately trying to build.

[00:28:58] Yeah. Project Aristotle was quite amazing at Google.

[00:29:02] You you've got the two books you also have have the toolkit and the other things you do around jobs to be done. Could you say a few words about.

[00:29:10] Sure. So know, I've been looking at jobs to be done almost for two decades now, and using it in my own work.

[00:29:18] But about six or seven years ago, I started to teach a course on jobs to be done so that I could learn what are the questions that people have and figure out what the best way. To answer those questions or what's the language that I need to use to explain jobs to be done. And that was prior to writing the book.

[00:29:35] So when I wrote the book, I felt fairly confident that I understood just to be done, but I also understood how to explain it and really break it down, but I'm not done. I think, and the field's not done. It's not like jobs to be done is static. after the book came out, we me and my business partner created a.

[00:29:54] An online resource called the jobs to be done toolkit JTBD toolkit.com and there's some online learning there where you can do some video courses. We also have live training that we do, but there's also some resources there some articles and things, and we do monthly. We do a, what we call a community.

[00:30:11] Where there's a group of two or three dozen people who are interested in jobs to be done, I interview one of them and then we have a big open conversation and really that, all of that, what I just mentioned was really to keep the conversation going. Around jobs to be done after my book to, to make it alive.

[00:30:26] Cause you write a book. It's static. It's ink on page on paper, but I wanted to continue the conversation because for me, the book is just a point in time. I did a lot of work before the book and the jobs to be done toolkit is what I'm doing after the book.

[00:30:42] What would be your key advice for people now? The pandemic started over two years ago now. They've seen whiteboards, they've seen mural. They've seen, they've tried. Out a bit. I think initially there was a lot of stressing around, general technology and it's going to be overwhelming and spend half the meeting, just getting the thing, working.

[00:31:03] What would you say are the, let's say key tips for people nowadays in terms of getting the most out of using whiteboards?

[00:31:09] Yeah, I think I think some of the initial trepidation is gone, but I still think. We need brave people to step up and lead conversations and design collaboration experiences.

[00:31:22] One thing the pandemic taught us was that a lot of meetings and a lot of collaboration and interactions with our colleagues was improvised. And I think when you're in person, you can get away with improvising a little bit more than you can when you're remote.

[00:31:35] And part of zoom fatigue for me, by the way, is that we basically just took our calendars and replicated it in zoom meetings, but then we didn't ask ourselves, did we need to meet at all? We also didn't ask ourselves, what are the rules of engagement? How are we going to get from point a to point B in this conversation?

[00:31:52] Because if you're just improvising on zoom, it's a lot more obvious that there's no real deliberateness or intentionality behind the interactions. So I think we need brave people to say, okay, we have this new set of technologies and this new work environment, which is sometimes remote sometimes in person sometimes.

[00:32:11] And to step up and be brave to be brave enough to use your imagination, to invent new ways to collaborate. The thing that I would orient to towards is using things like guided methods and there's thousands out there that you can find, right. For icebreakers, how to start a meeting, how to decide together, how to, brainstorm.

[00:32:32] To use deliberate methods to structure the interaction, to be a lot more deliberate about how you're going to collaborate. So you're not just improvising because again, improvising on zoom is what leads to some fatigue. Here's what I find. If you have a mural canvas open and you have an activity that's structured and you have a timer, okay.

[00:32:48] Everybody has five minutes to put their best idea down. Okay. We have 10 minutes to, to prioritize this. Time goes by so quickly. I get that a lot in my workshops loop that people go, how did you feel? Four hours so much? And I wasn't distracted people. Aren't distracted and they're not fatigued from it as well too.

[00:33:04] It's the structure that I put to it. I don't mean structure in terms of rigid. It's just that there's a game plan there. I have a game plan and I have the materials and using neural, I visualize. So everybody can see it and everybody can interact with it.

[00:33:17] So the combination of visualization and guided methods and structure to your meetings, it gets rid of zoom fatigue. When I first heard that term, I was like, what? What's that? Because I didn't experience it myself. And the other thing that I thought was what you need to be a little bit more intentional about how you're getting through your day of.

[00:33:35] Yeah. And so that's my biggest piece of advice is to structure and design. Essentially collaboration design, right? Design your collaborations.

[00:33:43] That's fascinating. And actually one thing you mentioned hybrid have you seen any kind of interesting ways teams or companies are using using neural and in a hybrid context?

[00:33:56] Yeah, sure, absolutely. And I think that's key that, that digitally defined workplace that I talked about, I think that's what is going to make hybrid a lot more. W I have seen teams doing the opposite. And by that, trying to let the people who are in person continue to work with sticky notes and whiteboards, then letting them, continue to sit at a desk without their own laptop or device.

[00:34:19] I don't think that's going to lead to a good hybrid experience. I think the better hybrid experience is to say whether we're in person. Altogether in person, whether we're hybrid and it's mixed. And whether remote, we have to be thinking about how are we going to do this digitally,

[00:34:34] and mural, just to focus on the digital whiteboard component, we do have apps for large touchscreens. We have apps for mobile devices. So if you are in person and you're entering a hybrid collaboration session with colleagues who are remote show up and have a device that you can interact with, because guess what? There's audio and video. There's. How do you chat with the people who are remote? And then if you have a virtual whiteboard, you're going to want to do that virtually as well too.

[00:34:59] I was just talking to somebody who said, yeah, we got together altogether. We were in person, they deliberately met in person and then they wrote things down on sticky notes and flip charts and they said, oh, what are we going to do tomorrow?

[00:35:13] Like they had no game plan. Once you put something out on a sticky note, they were like, oh, somebody's got to do it. And then you do the old fashioned. Let's take photos of it. Let's transcribe it. But as soon as you put something on a piece of paper, it's static. And I think what we have to be thinking about is fluidity, right?

[00:35:29] Because your day and day to day, you're going to move in and out of all of these different modes, you're going to have a call at nine in the morning, everybody's remote, then you might go to the office and half of the people are remote. And half of the people. And then later in the day, you have a meeting with your colleagues who are all in the office and the next day it's going to be a completely different combination on a daily basis.

[00:35:51] Each of us are going to be moving in and out of these different modalities of working remote hybrid, in-person hybrid, in-person remote. You're going to be going back and forth between these and your project is going to be going back and forth between these on Monday. We're all remote on Wednesday.

[00:36:06] We all go to the office together in between where all. So your project materials need to be fluid as well too. And move in and out the way to do that is to be thinking digital from the beginning. And we call that a digital first mindset, right? No that's great. That's great. .

[00:36:22] So the books are experience mapping and the jobs to be done. Playbook. There's the jobs to be done, toolkit, a website and is there any other place where people can look you up to find out more?

[00:36:37] Sure. I hang out a little bit on LinkedIn and if you want to reach out on LinkedIn and say hi and connect to me, I'd love to connect with folks who are like-minded.

[00:36:46] And then also. So it's at Jim callback on Twitter. I'm a little more active on LinkedIn, but I also I'm a little bit active on Twitter and things. I'll see it right away and retweet or comment or something like that. So LinkedIn and Twitter are another good place to find me. Great. Great.

[00:37:02] Thanks very much, Jim.

[00:37:03] Great. Thank you. Thank you very much.

Thursday, 31 March 2022

Managing asynchronously through the Russia-Ukraine war

My name is Lukasz Szyrmer. If you are new here, I am the author of the book Managing Remote Teams. I help teams thrive and achieve more together when working remotely.

In this episode of the Managing Remote Teams podcast, I speak with Liam Martin. Liam has been a remote work advocate for a long time, as a successful serial entrepreneur and innovator in this space. We dig into how being remote and asynchronous freed him up to respond effectively to the evolving Russia-Ukraine conflict, supporting his Ukrainian team creatively.

About Liam Martin

Liam Martin

Liam is a serial entrepreneur who runs Time Doctor and Staff.com — one of the most popular time tracking and productivity software platforms in use by top brands today. He is also a co-organizer of the world's largest remote work conference — Running Remote. Liam is an avid proponent of remote work and has been published in Forbes, Inc, Mashable, TechCrunch, Fast Company, Wired, The Wall Street Journal, The Next Web, The Huffington Post, Venturebeat, and many other publications specifically targeting the expansion of remote work.

Liam has also co-authored a book - Running Remote - focused on remote work methodology. In this revolutionary guide, Liam and his co-founder, Rob Rawson, have unearthed the secrets and lessons discovered by remote work pioneering entrepreneurs and founders who've harnessed the async mindset to operate their businesses remotely in the most seamless, hassle-free, and cost-effective manner possible.

Transcript

[00:00:00] Are you in Poland right now? Or are you in. Are you somewhere else? I think we are from Poland.

[00:00:08] I am from Poland. Yeah. So I'm from Poland, but I grew up in the U S and I'm back in Poland. And I lived in London for awhile.

[00:00:14] So I've got two of my team members from Ukraine that we ended up getting to Poland, and three of them were not able to to make it out, which was half of their fault and half our fault we should have actually just dragged them out of the country, but they refuse to go.

[00:00:35] And and it's quite rough there. And I'm sure it's probably really rough in Poland right now because there's just a kind of. For refugees that are coming across the border from what I understand it.

[00:00:45] Yeah. Yeah. I think we're up to 600,000 at the moment. And we've got a a housemate, my parents own that was recently empty outside the south of the city.

[00:00:56] We accepted a family of about 11 there, so they're just, as, give them a place to just figure out what's next possibly stay there for a while.

[00:01:07] So let me know if there's if I can make a donation or something like that, just for, to get them, like food for the next month. We've been trying to figure out what we can do here. We've actually had I've been in talks yesterday with. With a space X, because we got our, we have guys in Poltava and we have guys in Kharkiv, one guy in Kharkiv, and we can't get into Kharkiv, but we do have a courier that can get us into Poltava. We got solar arrays and a power bank system.

[00:01:39] So effectively they're power independent at this point. And it's not something that's going to run their entire home, but it's going to run basically Their computers and wifi and maybe a lighter too, or something like that. But if you can't get any communications up and running, then, there's no point in doing any of those things. And it's been a bit of a difficult time trying to get in touch with them with space X. They did that finally get back to me and they said we'll try to connect you with somebody today, but hopefully we can do it because I don't think they have more than a week before all those supply lines.

[00:02:14] Welcome. Welcome. Welcome to the managing rope teams podcast. Today. I am speaking with Lee and Martin running remote and the running of our podcast and the founder of time doctor and Liam in his Vilnius spare time is also writing a book. And whenever when, again, by the way, we'll never write one here.

[00:03:12] So the only one. So if you want to read a book written by me, this is the only book will be available. Yeah, there we go. There we go.

[00:03:21] The remote work world was a cottage industry before the pandemic, right? There was a very small amount of people there. We ran the largest conference on remote work In 2019. And that was 700 people in Austin, which we had to cancel, which was going to happen in April of 2020 was projected to be a thousand people.

[00:03:45] So that was at work right there like that was the ecosystem a thousand people. And and in, in January of 2024, approximately 4.5% of the U S workforce was working remotely in March of 20, 20, 40 5% of the U S workforce was working remotely. This is the biggest transition since the industrial revolution, but the industrial revolution took 80 years.

[00:04:08] We did it in March. And one of the things that I recognized when that transition occurred, Was that almost everyone. And I lovingly refer to these people in the book is pandemic panickers the people that I got phone calls from G 20 countries saying, Hey, we have 400,000 workers and we want to transition to remote work tomorrow.

[00:04:34] And my answer is I'm not the person to call and their response to me was who else do I call? You're one of those people that picked up the phone because it was such a small community. And so what I recognized was that. Everyone that's currently transitioning to remote work and is currently working remotely is effectively recreating the office remotely.

[00:04:57] So they're not recognizing all of the work that the remote pioneers have done over the last two decades to be able to understand that managing remote workers is not like managing on-premise in the office workers and the methodology that I believe that the vast majority of the remote work community basically built was asynchronous management.

[00:05:20] What we call the asynchronous mindset inside of the book, and the book specifically focuses on how to actually take that methodology and deploy it inside of a remote team, a hybrid team or an in-office team. It doesn't actually matter because we've recognized that we think that asynchronous management is actually just a better way to run a business, whether you're remote or.

[00:05:45] So let's dig into that a little bit. So what exactly is different about managing your synchronicity versus just typical management?

[00:05:57] So I think that you got reached out to, by vice Shelly. If I remember correctly by Shelly was the initial person that reached out through email to you. Me and by Shelly had been working together for years. She's managing the outreach for podcasts. And the last time that I spoke to by challis synchronously was about four months ago. So in that four month interim. We've worked on multiple different projects together and all of that work has been accomplished without me requiring to be in the same physical time zone as her, for a meeting.

[00:06:39] I think of it almost as the Netflix model versus the old school television model. I don't know if you're old enough for this, but for me, I remember trying to watch friends, the TV show that would come on at Friday night at 8:30 PM. If I wasn't in front of the TV at 8:30 PM. I would miss friends. I would miss that episode and I would have to actually listen to a rerun six months or a year later.

[00:07:07] Netflix is an asynchronous model. I choose when to actually consume that content. And basically that's exactly the same methodology that's implemented inside of businesses today, the employees inside of the organization can choose when to become distracted with what pieces of information in order to actually become more focused and more productive inside of the organization.

[00:07:32] There's a great book called deep work by my friend, Cal Newport. And I looked at all of these.

[00:07:46] I would love some pizza too.

[00:07:55] Yeah, no. And also pizza. So basically. The methodology is really trying to reinforce every single employee needs to reinforce what, as I said before, my friend Cal Newport coined, which is deep work, the ability for every single individual inside of an organization to have everything at their disposal to solve really hard problems inside of your organization.

[00:08:23] Because at the end of the day, any corporation is fundamentally just solving difficult problems. The more difficult problems that you can solve at a faster speed, the faster your organization grows. So the assumption is that you need collaboration and disruption and synchronous interactions in order to actually accomplish that goal.

[00:08:45] What the remote pioneers have discovered as that you do not need this system in place to actually achieve fantastic growth inside of your.

[00:08:54] So on the count Newport point. In his more recent book the world without email, he's talking about the hive mind so basically this whole idea of busy-ness , being notified through slack or teams or something what do you, think of that?

[00:09:12] We use slack but I turn notifications off another really good app that you can use as twist, which is. I slack design specifically for asynchronous work, run by mirror and to do list. They're at the tip of the spear when it comes to asynchronous communication and management.

[00:09:32] But I believe that any disruption, so inside of these organizations, the assumption is that getting an answer right now, we'll speed things.

[00:09:45] This is exactly. And this comes off of the premise, which I was, I wanted to touch on before, which is the idea that collaboration is good. And the more collaboration you do, the better your organization will be the reason why that occurs is because everyone has a sunk cost fallacy. They all get in their cars and they drive to one single place.

[00:10:05] They spend 90 minutes of their Workday driving to this one place every single day. And then they say, okay it's a collaboration buffet as much information as you possibly can. As much collaboration as humanly possible, it's indirect as much as humanly possible rote first organizations where that didn't occur, recognized we have an Alec heart method we can choose when we want to become distracted with collaboration.

[00:10:28] And they actually discovered that you need significantly less collaboration to actually achieve the same returns. And also more counter-intuitively sometimes collaboration actually has counter-intuitive effects towards everyone's overall productivity.

[00:10:43] I always say that if there's less than three people talking in a 10 person meeting, then those other seven people should just leave the room and get back to work.

[00:10:53] If people are actually participating in, they should be there. Whereas everyone else it's enough to yet inform some other way. And otherwise it just ends up being too much of a thing about status.

[00:11:03] It's a component of ego that works into this as well.

[00:11:06] And this is the other thing that I've been discovering while I studied some organizations that have gone back to the office as well, and figuring out why they went back to the office. And one of the underlying parts of this conversation, which no one really wants to talk about is a lot of these business owners liked the idea of having an office, where there were a thousand people in that office and the vast majority of the time he got to tell those people what to do that gave that person a power trip.

[00:11:43] I worked in a coworking space for a couple of years. And I have this woman in the book, this character in the book that I refer to as a tech startup Karen. And so she she would always yell to her other employees right in front of my desk and speak very loudly. I knew absolutely everything about her business and she never spoke to me. She didn't even know who I was. one time I remember her having a conversation with one of her employees, it was dressing her employee down and she said, listen, we need to get more revenue from local companies like Shopify and time doctor. And then the employee who knew me and everyone else knew me in the office, except for his woman who owned half the office. Just giving you context here. He said, you mean Liam's company. And she said, what?

[00:12:34] And then she just pointed to me and I pulled out one of my AirPods and I was like, yes, but obviously I heard everything that she was saying. I had been working in that office for two years. She didn't even know who I was and there's this presumption that, because I just sit at my desk and I'm quiet and I'm a relatively introverted guy and I just work away at my job that I'm not important.

[00:12:57] I think we're sitting on a new business model, a new way to be able to extract labor from the workforce. And I think it's just fundamentally going to be a more efficient model once you implementing synchronous work. So it's not going to be a choice for those people.

[00:13:11] You want to keep your really nice office. That's great. I really liked my horse, but I'm going to buy a car. It's just a more efficient model to be able to get around.

[00:13:20] Let's dig back into collaborations specifically. So you said that there's some counter-intuitive things around collaboration. What did you mean there exactly?

[00:13:30] Counterintuitive assumption that I discovered was that the more collaboration that you have inside of an organization, there is almost an exponential diminishing in returns. So the first hour of me of a meeting is incredibly productive, but then the fifth hour of that meeting is actually very unproductive.

[00:13:52] And so optimizing towards the minimum viable dose towards all of the synchronous versus asynchronous interactions is actually something that people should think about. And no one actually thinks about those things. No one says to themselves how much time should we spend in meetings? Has anyone asked that at any corporate meeting ever or any organization?

[00:14:16] No, because they think meetings are always good. Meetings are always going to make us move forward. When in reality, in my analysis meetings in sometimes counter-intuitively actually keep you exactly where you are or in the worst case we'll be back.

[00:14:34] Yeah. I liked the rule of thumb in the book by a high output management by Andy Grove, where he talks about the rule of thumb that about 25% of a manager's time should be in meetings.

[00:14:48] There you go. And that's like in a high-performance culture, right?

[00:14:50] In our organization and this isn't just something that this is something we invented, but it's been adopted through remote pioneers is the concept of the silent. So every week we use a Sonos or project management system.

[00:15:03] And I talk a lot about how technology is now, the office and the manager. And so a sauna actually works as both. So we have all of the issues that we want to discuss in our weekly standup meeting. And we discuss those things. They synchronously. So on some of these issues, we might have 40 to 50 comments, but if you've actually come to a conclusion, we take that conclusion. We put it to the top of the ticket and then we basically check that particular issue off. And if we have less than three issues that we can't solve a synchronously, we don't have a meeting. So we usually. Once or twice a month on average, where we'll basically just have a backlog of a lot of these issues that are not, that can't necessarily be solved.

[00:15:52] And the vast majority of the time, actually, ironically, when I've been looking at the tickets that can't get solved, it's almost entirely due to the emotional state of some of the team members inside of that meeting. It has nothing to do with the actual logistics or the hard data inside of those problems.

[00:16:13] Yeah, collaborations that interesting one. It also depends on exactly how you define productivity too. It's going to be different in every company, every industry, that kind of thing. I What are your thoughts on the relationship between the two in a remote.

[00:16:26] If I speak to 10 companies and I asked them what productivity means, you get 10 different answers. So I completely agree with you. When I look at companies that are hyper-growth companies, right companies that grow more than 50% year over year and stringing more than two of those years together, that's the definition of a hyper-growth organization.

[00:16:49] The best variable that I can define that equals productivity is: solving difficult problems that produce some type of innovation in the market that give them a strategic advantage in comparison to all of their competitors. So anything that you can do to be able to optimize for that is really the core piece that I see inside. Basically any company. And I think asynchronous management is one of the best methodologies that you can implement to be able to achieve those particular goals,

[00:17:23] so if you have really intelligent people inside of your organization, what should they be spending the vast majority of their time doing? Should they be managing other individuals? Absolutely not. That's actually the worst expenditure of their time.

[00:17:40] Don't put someone who has a PhD in artificial intelligence and have the manage other people, they should actually be executing on building, an AI model as an example. Should they be sitting in meetings? Absolutely not. They should actually just be focusing on solving those very difficult problems and anything that you can do to be able to put more of their productive Workday into that time is really the model that I think that inevitably everyone will adopt.

[00:18:11] Also, when you take a look at where people put their time the concept of the eight hour work day and the five hour work week, that's also a really incorrect way to look at productivity. What I really look at is what's the meaningful amount of output over, let's say a one month period, if you want to get super nitty-gritty on it. Cause I love looking at time. One of my other companies is time doctor recognizing that probably for those types of individuals, they can really only put in four hours and it can vary. The actual number is about four hours and 16 minutes, but on average, four hours per day of time into solving difficult problems.

[00:18:51] And if someone can deploy four hours into solving those difficult problems, you're going to be way more successful than the old model. I have a meeting at 8:00 AM to 9:00 AM. Then I get into work from 9:00 AM to 1130 and then I go to lunch and I get distracted for the next hour and a half. Then I go into a meeting after lunch, and then maybe I get another hour at the end of the day.

[00:19:12] Forget about that. We have like silent communication days. So days in which we shut down slack and all of our project management systems and our email, and we just focus entirely on getting deep work done. And those are some of the most productive days that we have all month because everyone can remove all of these distractions and just focus on getting those big, hairy, audacious goals solved.

[00:19:35] Still on the theme of some extent, collaboration. When you are collaborating with larger group around solving difficult problems, how do you make sure that people stay effective? So not so much efficient but that they're working together in a way that remains effective when you're doing this asynchronous management.

[00:19:57] So a lot of the times people have to get better at the written word. That's a big part of asynchronous management and proper collaboration.

[00:20:05] The other variable that I'll jump us over just for a second is the way that collaboration and the way that ideas were moved forward in synchronous organizations are almost entirely connected to and extroversion.

[00:20:22] So inside of asynchronous organizations, I believe that we're going to see the rise of the introverted leader, which is a very rare type of leader. We do see it in people like Elon Musk, as an example, he's an introverted leader, right? He's very much, I don't know if you've ever seen him speak in front of large groups of people, but he's horrible.

[00:20:43] He's very bad at communicating his ideas. He hasn't had any, maybe he has had training, but probably it didn't really stick. He's not good at solving those problems, but he is really good at having fantastic ideas that he can bring to fruition that he can execute upon.

[00:21:00] So inside of the old synchronous model, it would usually be the captain America, six foot, two football captain guy that would come in and say, I have an idea. It's going to be called Twitter for cats. We're going to call it katter.com. We're going to invest a billion dollars into it. And then everyone is convinced because he's just very charismatic at communicating that information.

[00:21:23] But then the person that's sitting there saying this is incredibly stupid. You're an idiot for even thinking about it because there, they don't have that same level of charisma and they can't convince people in the moment. They don't actually have their ideas adopted.

[00:21:40] Inside of asynchronous organizations. You can sit and think and reflect upon all of the communication that's happened from top to bottom and people that have that ability to be able to really craft fantastic ideas and also convince people through text form are usually the people that are going to have their ideas adopted at the end of the day.

[00:22:02] Basically better ideas will be adopted more often when we collaborate asynchronously.

[00:22:07] It's very difficult for me to be able to communicate synchronously, but in text form, I can think about my ideas and I can communicate my ideas a lot more elegantly than I can on a podcast as an example. It hasn't been utilized until literally the last five years effectively when asynchronous work really started to pop up as something that companies were seriously thinking about implementing inside of their companies.

[00:22:35] One thing I wanted to ask about is given the context now, , let's say the attack on Ukraine and the pandemic, big external risks for companies. You're your CEO. How does a company being a synchronous deal with that? So to speak.

[00:22:56] With Ukraine, this is a perfect example because I've never communicated more synchronously in the last few days than I've done in the last few days. So it's been a lot of synchronous conversations with our team members in Ukraine and then also our team members on the borders with Ukraine as well.

[00:23:16] We did get some of our team members out. Some of our team members are still in Ukraine and that is to me, the difference between management and leadership. So whenever we meet with people and we talk to them I don't need to know your numbers because that's already documented inside of all of our project management systems that we already have.

[00:23:40] We don't need to necessarily discuss what your goals are because we've already clearly defined what those goals are. What I talk about is how are you doing? What's going on in Kharkiv right now? What's the situation, how can I help you? Where can you go next? Those are the things that are really important and what your numbers were is probably the least important part of not only obviously these people's lives, which is way more important than any type of money that we'd make inside of the business, but more importantly, in a grander context showing people that we care about them as friends of ours. And not just coworkers. And those are the ties that I think will bind companies together, way better than, zoom calls on at 5:00 PM on a Friday where everyone must do culture at gunpoint,

[00:24:39] it's a 5:00 PM. Everyone gets together. We've got some beers that have been delivered to you, and we're going to play cards against humanity, but not the fun kind, the HR friendly kind. And we're all gonna sit on this call for the next 90 minutes. If you do that, pull your people, make it anonymous, ask them if it's.

[00:25:00] I could guarantee you 80% of them eat it and they do. They don't want to do it anymore.

[00:25:06] We bought a whole bunch of Oculus virtual reality headsets. We bought them for everybody. And we said, if you guys want to go play VR together, you can do it on company time, just go ahead. And what we were measuring was how many people would voluntarily get together to be able to do this type of thing. So measuring the dividend off of an investment into culture is the only real way that I actually think that you can see culture and you can see whether or not you're building meaningful culture.

[00:25:38] All this culture at gunpoint is fundamentally not going to be useful.

[00:25:42] Yeah. Culture is a big one. Definitely. It's like there's the play aspect of it, but also how things are actually done, how decisions are made, how the work is done. Once you do get into a remote environment, the subjective, the emotional side of that suddenly feels a lot stronger than it would be necessarily just in your office.

[00:26:01] We talked about culture so often inside of the tech startup world. No one really knows what that is. It's such a used term that everyone now we're first. For everything. From sociological perspective, culture is what unique actions and activities does your group do that other groups do not? That's the sociological definition of culture.

[00:26:26] When I looked at that and I said to myself, okay, what really defines our culture? Before the pandemic, we were a road that was a very unique thing. Not many other people did that. We also hire from anywhere on planet earth, we're in 43 different countries all over the world. That's a very unique variable that we have, we also have a very open liberal, democratic mindset towards ideas inside of our organization.

[00:26:50] So I've had a meeting with someone that was thinking about getting a a sex change operation one week. And then the very next week we had another team member that was thinking about getting a second life. Those are very unique things. And then you assemble all of those pieces together. You package that. And then you deliver that to your prospective new employee, your new team member. And instead of saying, Hey, this is who we are as a company. Don't you want to join us? I actually have the reverse perspective. This is who we are as a company. You better know that before you get into this, because otherwise this isn't going to work. So if this is not what you're interested in this is not the place for you. And I actually use it more as a weeding out device, as opposed to a unifying device, which is we have a very liberal perspective towards the way that we operate our business. The ideas that we have inside of our organization. There's a lot of different ideas, but as long as you don't hurt anyone else, you're welcome inside of this company.

[00:27:57] About a year ago, I believe base camp ended up having a very difficult time where about a third of their entire organization left. And it's funny because I love those guys. Their books have been seminal to me in terms of just where we're going in terms of not just remote work, but work in general and how to run a business, particularly a tech business. But even those guys, I think, fell into the trap of saying what is culture? Their culture kind of got away from them and they didn't stand up for what they truly are. And they let that culture be co-opted by the people inside of their organization, because they were trying to use culture as a unifier, as opposed to a divider. And I actually think that the vast majority of the times you should use culture as this is who we are. If you don't like. Please don't take this job because you're actually going to hurt more than you help. Long-term

[00:28:50] that's interesting. Flip there. So how was writing the book itself?

[00:28:57] Horrible for someone who has a, it was, so I had a. I had a collaborator who worked with me on the book, who is actually a seasoned writer.

[00:29:13] And I remember sitting down because we're working sync, we're working asynchronously. We work on this big Google doc together, and I remember spending an entire day on about two paragraphs coming up with a core concept, which was actually around how platforms are the new office and trying to communicate to in-office environments.

[00:29:36] What we mean by platforms are the new office. And he saw me working on these two paragraphs all day because you can see that inside of Google docs. And so we just ping me on slack Hey dude what'd you doing? Like I'm seeing what you're doing here. And it's, it seems like you're having some trouble.

[00:29:53] So we jumped on for a zoom call for five minutes. I explained what I was trying to communicate. And he wrote a version that was way better than the six hours that I had spent trying to work out those two paragraphs. And he said, listen, in the future, write down your broken thoughts, put it in the Google doc. And then let me worry about actually turning it into something that's going to sound good.

[00:30:17] So that actually ended up accelerating the book quite a bit, but it's just taking all of these pieces of information that outside of, maybe a thousand companies that were running remote first pre pandemic, which is insane when you think about it and these methodologies that have been built over the decades, I'm trying to basically encapsulate that and try to get that to the massive community of people.

[00:30:46] That are now saying I'm working remotely now or I'm working from home. But they missed the biggest part, which is actually how to do it.

[00:30:53] Right now? March 20, 22. So two years later what's the biggest misconception people have about remote work?

[00:31:03] almost every single phone call that I've had with a pandemic panicker that's tried to transition towards remote work is some version of, should I use slack or Microsoft teams? Should I use zoom or should I use Google meet? And if you're asking those questions, you don't actually know what questions to ask to solve your problem.

[00:31:33] So that's a big part that I think that almost every single company doesn't recognize, which is they're simply trying to recreate the office.

[00:31:42] And if I'm on zoom calls eight hours a day I had a friend of mine who he said, oh I think I've set up the perfect system. Everyone just logs into zoom at the beginning of the day at 8:00 AM. And we're all on this like big keyboard little heads. And then anyone can ask anyone else a question and can just go into a little separate room and talk about it. And I said do you think your employees. Like that, do they think it's a productive use of their time?

[00:32:16] And he said, I think so. And so we pulled them anonymously and found out that it was like 95, like one guy, like out of the entire group, everyone else said, no, I would much rather not do this. There were other ways to be able to communicate. There are a lot more effective and that is fundamentally asynchronous work again.

[00:32:35] It's this assumption that synchronous collaborative communication is the be all and end all. If you open up any MBA book, you'll see a ton written about how these types of collaborative synchronous versions of communication are the way to be able to build a business when in reality, actually, even though it speeds you up in the short-term in the long-term, it creates a much slower moving organization.

[00:33:06] I use the word bureaucracy a lot, but don't think about going to the DMV in the United States is bureaucracy think about efficient focused bureaucracy.

[00:33:16] Think about a military organization it's incredibly efficient at achieving a particular goal because they have processes and systems if you were. Almost all of the command structures that I see in the militaries across the world. People are given a goal, but they're not actually told how to achieve that goal.

[00:33:35] So they're given their own individual autonomy to be able to get to the goal that has been set inside of the organization. In that case, the vast majority of our military

[00:33:46] we have the same mindset inside of companies,

[00:33:48] if you're my man. And I am telling you what my metrics are. And then you tell your manager what my metrics are. And then that manager tells the boss what my metrics are. This is an incredibly inefficient system. We have the internet. We have the ability to be able to communicate seamlessly across planet earth, within a moment. I can see everything that everyone is currently doing, and I know the targets that everyone has, and I know whether they're achieving them or not achieving. Do I look at them all? No. Could I look at them all? Yes.So that's the differentiator again, inside of asynchronous organizations that synchronous organizations didn't necessarily seem to happen.

[00:34:28] For me, I never worked in one of these companies I've been working remotely for almost 20 years. So it was such a shock to me to see that's the way that business was done. Because I was built on the methodology, which is. I need to build a business in which I cannot communicate to anyone synchronously, I can not have a physical meeting or a phone call or a video call with everyone inside of the organization. If that is true, how do I build that business? That was basically how we came up with asynchronous management and not only companies like mine, but dozens of other companies that have now become incredibly successful organizations today.

[00:35:08] So why was there such a driver back then for you? What was going on that you needed to do it asynchronously specifically?

[00:35:16] So for me, it was really just my own personal perspective on freedom. I spend six months out of the year traveling when it's not COVID, a lot of our other team members do the same thing. Some of our team members are digital nomads, so they work from their computers. Or from their laptops anywhere on planet earth. And I realized that if I didn't have to make work a place, then I could live a life that is significantly more rewarding, at least to me then being in that cubicle or even being in the best office on the face of the planet, right?

[00:35:56] I've got the cash to be able to get a really nice office somewhere if I really wanted to. But is that fundamentally going to make me happy? I decided that it isn't. I'd much rather spend my time in Mexico city or in Playa Del Carmen or in in Bali or Barcelona in Spain. These are the places that I'd rather spend my time. Travel actually is one of the best things to make you a well-rounded individual to understand different cultures.

[00:36:22] We're talking about the the Russian Ukrainian war that's happening right now. The key to world peace is there should be one day a year. If I was the emperor of the world this would be my international holiday, which is every single person on planet earth flies somewhere else and has dinner. A group of people and a culture that they've never encountered before. And if you do that, you discover that everyone on planet earth wants effectively the same thing. And that's what travel has done for me. It's made me a much more, I think interesting person than when I was before I discovered travel in my early twenties. And once I started getting on that train, there was no getting off for me. So I wanted to be able to build a business that really encapsulated that and allowed me to be able to have that type of freedom. And only for myself, obviously I was starting it for myself, but then everyone that works inside of the company can have that freedom as well.

[00:37:26] What about scaling up when you're working in synchronously. How does that work when you've got a completely change as the company grows? How you manage things? How does it scale and what are the key takeaways you had as you've grown your company?

[00:37:38] That's one of the other key advantages of asynchronous organizations. Process documentation is effectively everything that the company does, everything that every individual does inside of the company is written down and documented, processed and digitized.

[00:37:58] So by challis, who reached out to you, there's about 40 different process documents that apply to the outreach of booking podcasts. Everything down to what kind of emails we should send, what follow-ups we should send the one-page press sheet that I have, how I schedule that meeting, what tools that we use to be able to do that the followup process. It's all documented.

[00:38:27] So by Shelly becomes the operator of that process and not the owner of that process. And those are two very separate things.

[00:38:37] If people become the owners of that process, then they all have sacred knowledge. And if all of a sudden, there's effectively, almost a world war that breaks out well, what happens to all of that information? It's lost for other forever.

[00:38:54] So instead when you become the operator of that information of that knowledge of those processes, then you can number one, make sure that process continues on regardless of the individual. But more importantly, you can scale that process because the actual process is also the manager.

[00:39:12] The documentation is not meant to be easy to understand. It's meant to be impossible to miss understand, and it's a very small shift in people's minds. But if you get to a point in which you say to yourself, nine out of 10 people on the street can come in and look at what's written down and get it and figure it out. And. Then you've got credibly, powerful weapon that you can use to be able to have, not just one person doing outreach, but 20,

[00:39:49] you get my point, which is the ability for having process documentation inside of an organization allows for scale to happen almost instantaneously because the processes are not only very easy for other people to understand, but more importantly, they actually provide the managerial layer.

[00:40:07] Another thing that we saw and that I've talked about in the book is that asynchronous organizations on average had a 50% thinner layer of managers. Then on-premise synchronous organizations because of the lack of that game of telephone. No one actually communicates how to do something on a very small scale.

[00:40:28] Do they communicate how to do something in comparison to synchronous organizations or communicate those metrics up the chain, which is classically what a manager does in the vast majority of synchronous organizations that I encountered. So all of those jobs are basically redundant inside of asynchronous organizations and therefore the person is saying to themselves what do I do?

[00:40:50] The only thing that you should really do is focus on whether or not that person's happy with their jobs and thinking structures.

[00:40:59] So going into the process documentation a little bit, you said that my salary was an operator of the process. So how was the process adjusted as requirements change or improved over time? I've seen that to be a difficult point for companies.

[00:41:16] The processes change with time. They're an organic model as opposed to an inorganic model and they're built on a Wiki system.

[00:41:23] If you go to Wikipedia is a perfect example.

[00:41:26] You can actually go to the debate tab on any Wikipedia entry and you'll have the discussion about what the version of. Article was six months ago, 12 months ago. And what it should be tomorrow, right?

[00:41:41] So there's active debates that are occurring inside of all of these processes. And the same thing effectively happens inside of our company and a bunch of other asynchronous organizations as well.

[00:41:50] So the process is the law of the land, but anyone inside of the company can actually change those laws. And if by Shelly says, I think I figured out a better way to be able to email people for outreach, for podcasts. And she can back that up with quantitative information and. You've convinced the stakeholders inside of that process. If that's a superior process, then that's the new version of the process that's adopted.

[00:42:16] In some contexts, if it's something that we need to redo quickly or something that like we just had a couple of years ago, we had a major change towards the Google algorithm. So it changed a lot of our search engine optimization processes.

[00:42:31] We paid people to be able to create more efficient processes. So every process that you could offer. And change. We would literally pay people out for it as a bounty. That's another really fast way to build out your processes is just pay people say, Hey, every process that you build that I accept, I'll give you 50 bucks.

[00:42:50] You will have processes coming out of your ears.

[00:42:52] Then that's the part that you need to control, which is when you release that money, you need to make sure that those processes are something that you would actually follow.

[00:43:00] a lot of the times, if there's a process that computer science engineer will put together, someone will read those processes. That's in another department like customer service and we'll say, okay, does someone on customer service understand this process enough that they could theoretically do it from a layman's perspective? If the answer is yes, then the process is adopted. If the answer is no, then again, you have made it easy to understand, but not impossible to misunderstand.

[00:43:34] So when you start with a company, helping them become better at remote, what's the first thing that you do in terms of that?

[00:43:41] If we're moving towards an asynchronous model, the first thing that I would do is implement.

[00:43:46] What are the biggest time sucks of your day? What do you spend the most hot your most time doing?

[00:43:51] And more importantly, after that, what sacred knowledge that you have, which is information that you have, and no one else has, I think about, ancient Egyptian priests, right? They had the sacred knowledge, which gave them power over everyone else.

[00:44:08] You need to get all of that stuff out. And this is also sometimes very difficult inside of organizations where you have a lot of B players that are saying to themselves the moment that I give away the sacred knowledge, you're going to fire me.

[00:44:26] And in some cases, actually that might be true. Maybe this person really does need to leave and there they have no value other than they're the only ones who know how to process payroll. And no one else knows how to do this in the company. And if we lose this person, we can't process payroll next week. That's definitely something you need to actually have more than one person know inside of the organization. Ideally everyone should be able to have access to that type of information. But what

[00:44:56] I to know about payroll

[00:44:59] in terms of the actual mechanics of it.

[00:45:01] Yeah, I get it. So what I tell those people that are scared about that is what I'm trying to do is create an environment in which you no longer have to be dependent upon doing just this one thing and only you doing it. This will free you up to be able to solve much bigger problems inside of the company and be able to solve problems that are new as opposed to solving old problems, which honestly, when you ask people really, what they love to do inside of their work. It's solving unique problems particularly the insight of technology companies, but in brick and mortar companies as well.

[00:45:43] So optimizing all of that information, getting that on a system and then empowering everyone to be able to get access to that information.

[00:45:53] The next thing that I would do is all of your goals. So we have a quantitative longitudinal measure for every single team member inside of the. So every single person has a goal that can be measured in some type of quantitative way. It's not get more customers as an example, that is not a goal. It is you need to increase the amount of leads that are coming into the website every month by 10%.

[00:46:19] And if it's 9%, you haven't achieved your goal. It's 11% you surpassed your goal. We review it every quarter and we report it every week, not bi-weekly or monthly every single week, so that you have that granularity and you have that longitudinal data. You can see those blips in the data and we make sure that's documented automatically.

[00:46:41] So no manager should ask you for that number. That number should ideally be completely automated, meaning the employee responsible for that goal and that metric doesn't even need to actually put it in anywhere. It just automatically happens. But in some cases that's not going to be the case, but on Monday morning, I'd better see those numbers there because that's a core part of your job.

[00:47:04] So that information can be communicated to everyone else. Once you have those two pieces in place, then you're going to actually do the scariest part of a transition towards asynchronous. And if you do those first two steps, you're actually doing better than 80 to 90% of companies that are in corporate America today, surprisingly which is crazy.

[00:47:24] But the third and scariest step is giving that information to everyone else inside of the organization. We believe that if everyone inside of the company has the same informational advantage as the CEO of the company, then they can be much more effective at their jobs. Number one, but then number two, when difficult decisions need to be made.

[00:47:49] When you have as much information as the CEO, you usually recognize why that decision needs to be made. And you agree with it. We have EMPS rating of 72 right now, which is best in class. Apple has 86, which is the best on planet earth. Most companies have EMPS ratings of about 30 and that is employee net promoter score.

[00:48:16] So net promoter score is how much would you use this product from one to 10 EMPS is how much would you prefer working at this company to one of your friends from one to 10? That's the only question that we ask and we ask it every quarter. And the reason why we have such high EMPS is because they say I've never worked in a company in which I know more about the company than the CEO.

[00:48:42] That is the single most important thing that gives them value, which is they know everything that I know, they know everything that the executive team knows, and it really does empower them to be able to say, yeah, this is why we had to make this very difficult decision. This is why we had to let this person go.

[00:49:00] Or this is why we had to pivot in this particular direction because of this. And it really helps with building the trust and autonomy inside of organizations that I think as of right now, a lot of companies are currently.

[00:49:18] I was joking about the payroll, do you follow an approach to being open about salary also like buffer did in the early days?

[00:49:25] Or what's whatever we're actually, we did run that experiment and it ended up resulting in a significant amount of disruption to our companies.

[00:49:37] We do follow Buffer's model when I think about it. So we have geographic locations where we'll have a base salary and then we'll have additions to that based off seniority. And then that information is available to everyone, but it's bands, it's not specific salary amounts.

[00:49:55] So you don't know that Leah makes 106,000, but you do know Leah makes between 80 and 120,000 as an example because he's within that band

[00:50:05] Last question in terms of chief human motivation, I think often that is tied to salary and at least some traditional corporate America, it's very tied to the specific person. What are your thoughts on how that affects collaboration in a remote environment. On software teams even though you have these methodologies like scrum, where you retrospect as a team, when you deliver as a team and you do everything as a team, it starts to break down because everyone gets paid individually and has HR processes individually. What are the differences from asynchronous or remote?

[00:50:50] That's something I didn't necessarily look at in a deep way, but I see it. And just in terms of how people are paid, as it applies to asynchronous organizations, it's an interesting point.

[00:50:59] I can tell you the way that we look at that problem. So we have two separate basically silos of pay. When we look at increases just last year, we had zero to 5% increase for everyone in the company dependent upon the growth of the organization.

[00:51:21] So what was the growth? What's the goal for the company? We want to grow 78% year over year. Okay. if we surpass our goal, everyone will get the 5%. If we meet our goal, everyone will get two and a half percent. If we don't meet our goal and dependent upon how many points we are below that maybe we're going to get one to 2%, that's zero to 5%. And this is just that these numbers change dependent upon the year that we're currently working on it.

[00:51:49] The second silo is individual additions to that goal. So what did you do as an individual that helped move that particular core number forward and that zero to 5%. So where you absolutely critical towards the success of meeting our goals? Yes. You get the full 5%. Were you doing a generally good job? And everyone was generally happy with. You got a two and a half percent or, Hey, you know what? You actually didn't do a very good job. The goals that we set were misunderstood and you didn't hit the numbers that you were supposed to hit, you're going to get a 1% or 0% increase.

[00:52:30] So if the company meets all of their goals and you were an extraordinarily successful team member, as it applies to those goals, you'll get 5% plus 5%. You'll get a 10% for the year. And you know that there are people that get that inside of the company. I didn't get that. I can tell you at the end of the year. That is information that we we do give everyone the core number, right?

[00:52:58] Zero to 5% for company growth and goals, because everyone knows that individual number we do keep private reason being is because we don't necessarily want to. Embarrassed, any particular team member that maybe wasn't getting a piece of information that they would have had, but also take into consideration that's something that when you think about the only information that we keep from the organization or serve from the rest of the organization are just pieces of information that might embarrass other team members outside of that our P and L is public.

[00:53:32] If you work in the company, you can have access to it. We updated every month. The we have an interactive dashboard. How many customers we have? Who are they? How are they growing? How are they compressing? What's our churn rate, right? How, what experiments are we doing inside of the company? We have something called Thursday updates, which is every department head actually breaks down the four to five core things they did that week. And then it links to all of their core metrics for that particular department. And anyone in the company can get access to it and play around with it. And they're not just the ones that we prepare for that update. They are the actual tactical documents that we work off of.

[00:54:11] So again, that's pretty scary for some people I've pitched this to quite a few synchronous organizations and they've said, hell no would never do that because they think actually a lot of people are going to quit. But the other thing that I would push back to them, which is maybe it's time for them to quit.

[00:54:29] Maybe you shouldn't have these people working in your organization. If they're so easily going to quit, there's something wrong with your culture. There's something wrong with your mission and what the goal of this organization is. That is creating this environment where people want to jump ship, at the first hint of something going wrong inside of the organization.

[00:54:55] If you just are totally honest with everybody and upfront, they will respect you a lot more and they'll want to work at your company.

[00:55:00] Great. Is there any particular place that you want to direct people?

[00:55:05] Bobcat's would be great. I think running remote.com is the best spot to go. We are going to run our in-person conference, May 17th and 18th in Montreal, Canada. I don't know if I can convince you to come Luke, but I think it would be awesome if you did.

[00:55:22] It's fantastic. And it's going to be really nice. It's. Time. So it's not going to be cold. we've just removed a lot of the mandates. So it's very easy to be able to get into Canada at this point with with COVID. And then outside of that, probably the YouTube channel is another really great resource.

[00:55:40] youtube.com/. That is a place where you will be able to get access to all of our talks for free. So we publish all of our talks after the fact obviously going to the conferences, the best thing to do, to be able to have in-person communication and networking with people. Even asynchronous companies have like team retreats every year.

[00:56:02] We think of running a remote as a team retreat for remote work and the remote work community, but all of those talks are up there for free. And if you have any questions, you can just pose it there and I'll get back to you.

[00:56:13] Oh, and also the book so running remote.com/book, that's where you can, pre-order the book. And there's a ton of different partners that are really doing a fantastic job at helping us out with launching this thing. So we have a lot of re really great pre-order offers for people that are interested in purchasing the book right now and getting a whole bunch of extra stuff.

[00:56:37] Great. Thank you. Thank you very much.

Tuesday, 1 February 2022

How to Get Remote Teams into Flow with Diane Allen

About Diane Allen

Diane Allen, The ‘Own Your Potential’ Speaker and Violinist, is an Award-Winning International Speaker, Peak Performance and Flow State Expert. She is known for her Experiential Keynotes that have helped thousands of people around the world to break through their performance gaps and unleash their potential. Her proprietary process helps to increase the bottom line by empowering people to be at their best anytime, anyplace, no matter how high the pressure. She was the Concertmaster (lead violinist) of the Central Oregon Symphony for 15 years, a well sought-after Violin Teacher of 28 years, and the author of Sixteen Music Workbooks sold worldwide. She has been the keynote speaker for Women’s Conferences, Talent Development Professionals, Human Resources Associations, along with many others. Her flow state work has been published on IDEAS.TED.COM, and her TEDxNaperville talk has been elevated to the main TED platform. For more information please visit https://dianeallenspeaker.com

Links

Transcript

[00:00:00] Welcome. Welcome. Welcome back to the managing remote teams podcast. And today we have Diane Allen who is a speaker, a performance and flow state expert. And she's led the as the lead violinist, the central Oregon symphony for 15 years, and also taught violin for almost 30 years. And Is basically a flow expert.

[00:00:29] And I've invited her today to talk about how flow operates amongst groups of people and individually, and how we can apply that in our remote teaming contexts. So Dan, how. How did you get into music originally? Let's start there. Maybe.

[00:00:51] I am very fortunate to have been raised in Cleveland, Ohio, which is a hotbed of world class cultural organizations, including the Cleveland orchestra.

[00:01:03] Now I know that people who are aware of the classical music scene have their favorite orchestras? I know that the Cleveland orchestra is in at least the top five worldwide. You could pick yours. Of course I'm pretty biased. And and so my mom was the one who would fill up our family calendar with cultural events.

[00:01:23] We went to Shakespeare plays. We went to the Cleveland museum of art and of course we went to the York. And there was a particular concert. I was so little Luke that I was sitting in this seat and I couldn't like th the chair would fold up on me. Like I was so little, I couldn't, my legs couldn't hold the chair down.

[00:01:45] Those bounty where the bottom of the sheet bounces back up. Yeah. And I was that little we're sitting in the Cleveland orchestra and they played Prokofiev's Romeo and Juliet at the time, all I knew was that as soon as the conductor gave the downbeat, the force of the music literally felt like it pinned me to the back of the chair. I had goosebumps all over. It felt like my hair was sticking straight out. It was so intense. And when you're, this is the classic idea of group flow, you get a core group of people in flow, and then it just exponentially influences everybody in the audience. You've got everyone United through this music and I experienced that.

[00:02:34] In in that very young age. And when my parents said, so what do you want to play? I had already found fallen in love with the violins, watching their bows go up and down. And so that's how it all started. It was literally a flow experience, a giant group flow experience with just a tremendous impact.

[00:02:57] That's amazing. Yeah. Yeah, no, I think those early years are critical in terms of getting getting people interested in music, for sure. In terms of flow how do you. Define it for practical purposes, I guess when you're going into work with someone or work with a group.

[00:03:15] I'm so glad that you asked that question because people hear the word flow state and they go running. They're like, okay yeah, that's pie in the sky, thinking kind of thing.

[00:03:25] And it's woo or whatever. But the practical application is what I am. About the flow state is a state of mind. The neuroscience is such that there's a release of hormones into our brain and they're all the peak performance hormones. The ones that help have us rise to the occasion, the ones that, that set us up to, to go beyond what we've ever gone before.

[00:03:54] And they are. Followed by the neocortex AMSA, which dramatically increases learning speed and the prefrontal cortex temporarily shuts down. And this explains why. Talk about flow is losing all sense of time and losing like a sense of yourself. And that's because the prefrontal cortex, when that temporarily shuts down, your internal critic is silent.

[00:04:18] And so you're free to follow all of these other thoughts that without shutting them down. So it's literally a thought pattern. It's something that physically happens within us now. How people describe it I'd like to call them the key indicators of being in flow state, because this is helps people to become aware is losing all sense of time, losing all sense of self ideas and insights coming in from out of the blue things, coming together with a sense of ease.

[00:04:46] Let's say you've been practicing this one tennis stroke over and over again. And you're struggling one day. It just happens with these. So it's like maybe you're in the middle of you're grappling with something at work and it's clunky and it's awkward.

[00:04:58] And then one day you lose all sense of time. You're highly productive and it just comes together with these. So that's why you use these key indicators to say, oh, I remember when I was in flow states. There's also a positive feedback loop, this, which we're going to go in depth with, because this is key for.

[00:05:18] Individual flow and group flow. So on an individual basis, the more you get into your flow state, the more you get out of it because you're operating at such a high standard, and then you get excited. So then you get more into it. So that's this positive feedback loop and musicians talk. It's like the more I get into the music, the more I get out of it, the more I get out of it, the more I get into it.

[00:05:43] And then the last. Which hits on the mental health spectrum is that you people do feel happiness. This is why flow is positive psychology. This is taking the look at what are we like when we're at our best and when we're at our happiest state and how can we reverse engineer that. That's basically what positive psychology is.

[00:06:08] So we do feel elation. We do feel exuberating we do feel joy and purpose when we are in flow.

[00:06:17] The positive feedback loop you were mentioning, is this kind of the details of how you slip into that state or what do you mean by that?

[00:06:28] It's just a key indicator that you are in it. Okay. That's how I would best describe it right now, but That positive feedback loop occurs on an individual basis, which is where we have to start. And then we could build onto group flow for. Yeah. Okay. Okay.

[00:06:48] When I've came across this concept originally, I think it was actually also in a music context. Cause it was an an, a biography of Eric Clapton's where he was talking about being in flow. But I think there, and then also looking at six-month all these work, like I think at least at the time it was very It was clear what the characteristics of flow were, but in terms of a not quite prescriptive, but like a how to, of getting into it. It was a little bit hard to pin down back then.

[00:07:17] Yes. Let's talk about that.

[00:07:20] Okay.

[00:07:21] So a flow was triggered at the intersection of skill and challenge, so let's see You're a manager and you have an employee that is underperforming and and you're scratching your head. Why? You could actually have a dialogue with them and ask them, are you feeling challenged by your work?

[00:07:41] Because if they're not, that's not going to ignite that flow state, that's not going to interest them right now. It could also be that the challenge is so high, that it shuts them. If you think about dialing things up and dialing things down, there's a sweet spot. So for example, if the challenge is not enough, then you need to up to the challenge, give them a greater challenge in a way that they respond.

[00:08:09] So for example, for one person, a timeline is a challenge. Okay. You have to have this done by noon today. And some people that's going to knock them down. It's going to get in their way. But some people, they really rise to that occasion. So you have these conversations with people, ask them what, what challenges you, what are the things that you like to be challenged by then?

[00:08:33] If the challenge is way too over the top, then it's a matter of having a conversation and breaking it down into small. Challenges so that they can, step their way up.

[00:08:43] For example, I can practice here in my room, but there's something about being on stage that brings on that challenge piece. So typically when I'm on stage, I know that I'm going to play better than I do in the practice room. It just it, it ignites the flow. And so when you mentioned Eric Clapton, the thing is that musicians and artists, we regularly practice getting into flow. This is something that everyone's wired for, but it's just so happens that in the arts we're more versed in getting into it.

[00:09:21] So it's a matter of okay. If you get into your flow state and you're cooking in your kitchen, you love making bread. Let's say it's sourdough bread, right? Let's get really specific here. And you've got lots of different challenges with sour dough bread. I don't remember what they are, but I know that they are, as the people who are really into sourdough bread, we'll go on about all of the different channels and you can get lost in all sense of time.

[00:09:46] And so now we get to your second question, which. Mihai cheek sent me a high was very like how do we get into it? And this is where my Ted talk comes in because I had to figure out how to get into it on a daily basis as the lead violinists of an orchestra, because it, my, it, I had to always be at my peak. So I reverse engineered it.

[00:10:13] So let's say you're in your kitchen. You're making your sour dough bread . Okay. Where you are as in your kitchen, that's where you get into your flow state. The most, what you're doing is you're making sourdough bread. That's what you're doing on the outside. The real question is what are you doing on the inside?

[00:10:36] So one, person's going to say I'm being strategic. Someone else, with regards to sourdough bread, right? Somebody else might say, I'm being creative. Somebody else might say, oh, this is all about problem solving for me. I love the problem solving somebody else might say, oh, this is nurturing. I'm nurturing my family. I'm pouring my love into the bread that I'm cooking for them. And so everybody gets into their flow state in their own unique way.

[00:10:58] What you do on the inside is your project to figure out because this is your most compelling internal self motivator. And if you're a manager and you're working with somebody, this is the conversation you have with them.

[00:11:14] The first question is where are you when you get into the first state, the most, what are you doing is the second part. Outside. Okay. I'm working on a spreadsheet on the outside. What are you doing on the inside? That's that coaching piece. And then why is the last question? Why is it so meaningful?

[00:11:35] Because purpose pulls out the best in all of us. So where, what, why I have that? I have a handout for this. We'll talk about that later. So it's a worksheet that, that people could use to for themselves and to coach other people through. I call this a flow strategy, what you do on your, on the inside is your most compelling internal self-motivator and knowing what you do on the inside.

[00:12:00] Information that you can use to get into your flow state on purpose and make it less elusive. Why it's so meaningful as your most compelling as external self motivator and knowing your, knowing what purpose is really pull at your heartstrings. That helps you to tap into your flow state with purpose.

[00:12:27] And so I call this a flow strategy, what you do on the inside and why it's so meaningful is your first strategy.

[00:12:36] You identify your internal strategy to be able to then transfer it to other contexts? Is that,

[00:12:42] so it was first of all, to repeat it, I'm having a bad day. Okay. Let me remember. I sour go.

[00:12:50] It's just not going well today. Okay. Maybe I just need to throw out the batch. All right. Now I'm to remember, oh, it's nurturing. I'm not feeling like I'm nurturing right now. Let me get into my nurturing spirit. And I'm being silly, but you get it.

[00:13:03] if you're working on an Excel spreadsheet and you're grappling with it the, Another really important thing is that interruptions are the biggest killer of the flow state.

[00:13:12] And 90 minutes is a really good arc of time for people to turn off all distractions. If you're working from home, put the sign on your door, shut off your cell phones, and just. Even if you're feeling like you're grappling with 90 minutes, something's going to happen midway through and you'll tap into flow.

[00:13:33] If you just dedicate 90 minutes to whatever topic you're working on, whatever you have to do. That's another way to set yourself up. On an individual basis, you want to figure out what your flow strategy is, so that you can repeat it. Yeah. And get into it more regularly. So you can have those peak moments of high productivity out of the box, thinking things, coming together with these and enjoy your work. But what you said was, okay, now, do you take it to other areas in your life?

[00:14:08] And yes. So I'll give you my example. My first strategy for playing music is on the inside. What I'm doing is I feel like I'm sharing the message of the music. Why that's so meaningful is for me music is a universal language. So that experience I had when I was so young at the Cleveland orchestra, where everyone is United through the music was just a really profound experience.

[00:14:33] And so I have been on stage with audience sing-alongs where everybody's together through the music. And I'm up there crying in the middle of a concert because it just moves me. So bringing people together through unity is a purpose for me. What I'm doing on the inside is I'm sharing the music. So I was Transitioning away from the orchestral career inches speaking and you know what that means when you're changing career, you have to go networking and I hadn't gone networking in years.

[00:15:02] Super fish out of water and I'm at this event. And if we're looking at skill and challenge, right? So obviously talking is this. And connecting with people is a skill. You could talk about all these skills and it was just really awkward trying to break into these conversations. And I found myself, actually, I left the room came back and I was like, you know what?

[00:15:28] Isn't talking to people away from me to share. And aren't these new connections uniform. And it occurred to me that I could use my flow strategy with my music in a conversation. And that's all it took. I started talking with people. I started telling stories. I started having fun. I was sharing experiences, asking them questions and I was able to really enjoy myself.

[00:15:54] Using your first strategy to get you to thrive when you're outside of your comfort zone is a big piece.

[00:16:00] I can imagine how that could be used in different ways. What about with groups? So you mentioned initially that it spreads. Let's say you have one person in a group, like on a remote team. That's in a flow state. Yes. What happens then, or yeah. What happens then? Or what can you do if anything, to help the group get into flow?

[00:16:25] it does start on the individual level. I noticed that the more I got into the music. The more my students would get into the music. The more I got into the music, the more the orchestra would get into the music.

[00:16:40] And the more I got into the music, the more the audience got into the music. And so Stanford researchers on the topic of influence have specifically identified that passion is persuasive and confidence is contagious. Going back to the positive feedback loop. Okay. So that is where on an individual basis, the more you get into it, the more you get out of it, more you get out of it, the more you get into it.

[00:17:12] So in order to understand how this works in a group situation, let's take a look at biology. How do positive feedback loops function in biology. So you can tell I'm like getting all excited to share this I'm smiling. So apple trees let's take a look when an apple is exposed to the gas, ethylene it ripens, but when apple ripens, it releases the gas ethylene.

[00:17:43] So now all of the apples around it are exposed to that guy. And so then they will ripen. And so because of this apple trees are known to ripen all at the same time. So instead of a chain reaction, it's exponential. So when you get one person in their flows, Yeah, this is how I led the orchestra. I knew I had to be in it.

[00:18:11] Okay. And I knew that it would be infectious. And which is a terrible thing to say during COVID, but. Contagious. We're talking about being contagious in a good way. So good contagiousness. So if we take a look at the heart math Institute, their findings are that the electromagnetic field of the heart reaches out 15 feet all around you and the brain only. So when we are tapped into our flow state, both on purpose and with purpose, not only are we engaging all 40,000 neurons in our heart, but we are exuding our energy, 15 feet all around us. And so you could tell, even though we're remote right now, I am filling this room right with my energy.

[00:19:06] So that becomes that contagiousness. And so like ethylene to apples, the energy, we exude 15 feet around us gets all of the people around you into their 15 foot circumference, just like the ethylene to the apples. This is why we have group flow experiences in music all the time.

[00:19:30] And is it also quite exponential slash instantaneous or it is.

[00:19:37] Okay. Let me give you an example. Chief operating officer of a medical center. She came to me because she was having communication issues with her team and they she's a quiet person. And she said that people would interrupt during the meetings. She couldn't figure out why they would be so rude and then they would point a finger at her for lack of leadership.

[00:19:58] We figured out how does she personally get into her flow state? We have to start with the person. So the first question is where are you wedding? You get into your flow state the most for her it's at work. What are you doing on the outside? She's having one-on-one conversations with people.

[00:20:19] What are you doing on the inside is the second question for the what part? And she said, I put aside my thoughts and I deeply listen. Deep listening is known to get people into their flow state. Why is deep listening? So meaningful for you? And she said it was because the deeper she listens, the deeper she connects and connection is what touches her to the.

[00:20:50] So at our next team meeting, she opened by stating the main objective of the meeting and that she wanted to take the time to listen to each person's point of view. So she set herself up to listen to get into her super power. as she's listening to each person, she was astounded because. Everyone else was listening.

[00:21:19] Yeah. And then as soon as the last person finished speaking, there was like one of those pauses. And because she had just created this space where everybody was listening to each other, they had this spontaneous brainstorming session, all of a sudden they're solving problems with all kinds of innovative solutions.

[00:21:37] So she initially got into her. By herself. The last thing she was expecting was that it was going to trigger that synergistic state of group flow. That's what happened. I'm going to share one more story with you.

[00:21:52] Yeah, sure.

[00:21:53] Linda, she she's a high school math teacher. She's a friend of mine and she received a grant to to develop. It was high school math to develop a high school math program that teenage students can relate to. And so she assembled a cohort of teachers and they began the brainstorming session and the closer they got to the deadline, the less creative they were. So this was a case where the deadline was a challenge,

[00:22:21] it was like somehow getting closer to the deadline was overwhelming them. So she, she asked me, what can I do? How can I lead my team through their creative slump? So what we did was we started with Linda's flow strategy. Where are you when you get into the flow state, the most I'm in the kitchen.

[00:22:38] What do you do? Painting and she likes doing abstract painting. And if you don't know what abstract painting is, it means that it's there's it's made up there's no, it's not like you're painting an apple or an object or anything okay. So she's doing abstract painting. What are you doing on the inside?

[00:22:55] And I kid you not, she says I'm looking for patterns out of chaos. Everyone gets into their flow state and such a unique way. And for her to have that self insight. Why is finding patterns out of chaos, meaningful for you? That's the last question why? And she said, because those patterns become knowledge and knowledge becomes power and freedom.

[00:23:20] And this is exactly the kind of thinking you need to create new math curriculum.

[00:23:29] She was well-suited for this right now. Now you can't make this stuff up, but I love this example because it really hones it. And exactly what makes Linda tick and when you know your first strategy and it's different for every one of us, how you get into this optimal state of thinking is what makes you tick, it's as unique as your thumbprint.

[00:23:56] Okay. She goes back to the team. She brings me in, we talk about the three questions to where the what and the why we did peer to peer coaching. They all coach each other through finding their flow strategies. Then we took the question of why is it so meaningful? And we applied it to the project of designing curriculum that meant high school math students can relate.

[00:24:21] Obviously it's meaningful for these teachers, right? So we unified them through one purpose. Cause everyone's flows strategies. They have their own purposes. So we unify them through one purpose for the math curriculum. Last step is remember skill and challenge. So we took a look at the challenges and we walked through and clearly identified all of the challenges that they were facing.

[00:24:49] And we mark them down. They talk them through and after, like there was really very little to do after that because they just spring to life with that information. And Linda said that they stayed creative through to the end of the project and they far exceeded her expectations.

[00:25:06] So those are a couple examples of really how all of these pieces fit together.

[00:25:11] The order in which it works is quite interesting. in a more technical context, there's this word orchestration, which is how all of this comes together. Like in an orchestra, which, you know, a lot more about, than I do . There is a certain pattern and a certain order, which

[00:25:26] and music being, being a universal language, you're not dealing it's operating on a different level than speaking language, right?

[00:25:33] Yeah. Different part of the brain and all that category. Yeah, no, these are great.

[00:25:37] Are there any resources or things that you've found over the last year and a half since all of this craziness started that that really changed things for you in terms of, in terms of the topic of flow or professionally any interesting resource or something like that you might want to possibly.

[00:25:56] If you're familiar with Adam Grant, who's a very well known organizational psychologist. We had a New York times article in April and it was coining at that time, the the predominant emotion of 2021 in April of 2021 was. The topic of languishing and and we do languish when we're, I've had to struggle with it too with the isolation and not having, the social contact and stuff.

[00:26:33] And so I've had to be proactive about making sure that I do call my friends regularly and I do, do social zooms and things like that. But languishing on the mental health spectrum is exactly halfway. So you have depression at the bottom flourishing at the top languishing in the. And guess what the solution was.

[00:26:55] Luke and I, Adam Brandt in the New York times, it was to get into your flow state.

[00:27:02] There's a second article that came out in Lee. This is the best one to leave. In October, I was October 13th, 20, 21 Harvard business review. I don't remember exactly what the title of it was, but you can find it easily.

[00:27:20] And it's what people can do to engage employees now. What can you do now? And there, what they did was say comb through all the research and they came with the top three tips. That, that people can implement right now. Number one was connecting what people do to what they care about. And if you just check out the flow strategy system exactly on what people care about.

[00:27:51] So if you want to really help somebody as a manager, who's struggling, who's feeling disconnected and at least help them to connect. What their work is to something that they really care about. So that's in the Harvard business review. Look that one up too. Yeah. Yeah. I think I recall that also, but yeah, no, that's great.

[00:28:15] They're both great. They're both great articles. Absolutely.

[00:28:17] In terms of, next steps or things you would want people to look at?

[00:28:20] I have A URL for people to go to and I will send it to you in case I recited incorrectly right now, but I'm pretty sure it's HTTP colon slash tiny url.com/white paper, 2021. If you go to that, you're going to get three resources. You're going to get. A link to the Ted talk, which is a synopsis of everything I talked about.

[00:28:49] However, there wasn't time in the talk to go through the group flow, it does go in depth with the individual. I have a flow strategy worksheet that you can use for yourself and to use to coach others. And then I do have the white paper there for people to see how to apply this. What are the steps to apply a culture of at the workplace.

[00:29:15] It's interesting stuff. I took a look at it recently yeah highly recommend it.

[00:29:18] You can email me directly if you have any questions. If you want to talk more about this Diane @ Diane Allen speaker dot com. Okay, great.

[00:29:28] Great. Thank you. Thank you very much.